Book Review: The Girl Who Drank The Moon

The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill is one of the freshest stories I’ve read in years. If you love fairy tales, strong storytelling, lyrical writing and a bit of quirkiness, this is the book for you.

My top ten reasons to love The Girl Who Drank the Moon:

1. Wonderfully weird  –  It is a quirky blend of dark fantasy and humour, a super cool blend of ~Oooh~ and HA! It’s a story that tugs your heart-strings and tickles your sides. The lyrical prose soothes while the stark truths stab you in the heart. It’s disturbing, entertaining, heartwarming, intriguing, satisfying … and plain old good.

2. Adorable characters:

  • My Luna – A Mini Foxie x Jack Russell Terrier.

    Luna – How can you not feel for this kid? She’s literally out of control, but she’s so lovable and feisty and unique. Nevertheless, steps must be taken to contain the child, and the effects are drastic and rather sad. It’s reminiscent of  how kids today are medicated with psychotropic drugs like Ritalin. I know (professionally) such medications can be helpful and are (sometimes) necessary, but what’s lost? Are those losses quantifiable? Are they retrievable? Laying aside the big philosophical and ethical issues of sedating children, the real reason I was attracted to this book was the protagonist’s name. Luna! It’s such a pretty name. (Luna is my darling little doggie’s name. When I saw “Luna” in the book’s summary, I  knew this was a book for me!)

  • Fyrion, the stunted dragon who believes he’s enormous, is completely endearing. He had some of the funniest lines in the book. I liked him so much I want to name a future pet Fyrion, but it would have to be a reptile, and I can’t go there so…
  • Xan the misunderstood old witch. What a great character. Generous, kind and principled—and she makes mistakes.
  • Glerk, the swamp monster-poet and theologian  is so steadfast, so stable.
    Put the four together, sprinkle some Kelly Barnhill brand pixie dust, and KaPOW! Magic and delight on the pages.

3. Fantastic world building – “In the beginning was the bog … the bog is the poet and the poet is the bog …” Sounds silly here, but in the world of the book, the swamp monster’s origin story was perfect. Then there’s the wood and the bog and the volcano. The dreadful history of the Protectorate. The Sorrow Eater’s spectre. Magic that thrums and glows in Technicolor with flashes of silver. The shameful politics! So much to admire.

4. The lyrical writing – I noticed quite a few reviewers who tired of the writer’s repetition. It is true that the author’s makes great use of repetition, but it’s not arbitrary. The Mad Woman repeats, “She is here, she is here, she is here. ” It’s both a symptom of her madness and a device in the book. It was cleverly used, when her daughter picked up the phrase. To the nay-sayers, I suggest they “hear” the prose rather than just read it. It sounds sublime. Listen to the audiobook to experience the musicality of the prose. You may change your mind.

5. And speaking of the audiobook, the narration was pitch-perfect. Narrator Christina Moore gives a  stupendous performance. It was beguiling and heart-rending and joyful. A lot of my attraction to Xan had to do with the narrator’s voice. There was something beguiling about Xan’s voice. I rarely pick audio books by the narrator, but I will definitely look for out for her.

6. The storytelling – intriguing, exciting, and ultimately satisfying.

7. The cover – (a little in-text joke there, not a typo) The cover. It’s tantalising!

8. The words – Kelly Barnhill  lavishes beautiful, challenging words on her young readers. (She says she had fifth graders in mind when she wrote it. I love that she extends rather than simplifies.) This book may make its readers into logophiles.

9. The fluid concept of family – This story portrays different types of families. I especially like the “family” of Xan, Fyrion, Glerk and Luna. The ending of story initiates a beautiful new family constellation (I’m treading carefully to avoid spoilers…). Kids in adoptive, kinship or foster homes may be able to relate and find encouragement in the variety of loving, positive arrangements the book portrays.

10. Uplifting themes – Love and hope triumph over malice and sorrow. More than ever before, in this shifty, grey age of fake news and imploding politics, we need stories of hope and love .

How Good?

4.7 stars good. A few niggly little things made me scratch my head, but none was serious enough to mar my enjoyment of the book.

I have ordered a physical copy for my favourites shelf — that’s how good.

If you’ve read it, I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

Read (and like) more of my reviews on Goodreads.

Image Credit

Flock of Geese, Photo by Ethan Weil on Unsplash

Monthly Reading Round-Up – February 2014

Talk about genre-blending! February’s reading smorgasbord gave me a belly-full of flavours I don’t often savour:

  • Historical fiction in graphic novel form
  • Steampunk
  • A ghost story
  • Chick Lit
  • Children’s literature

I’m happy to report the weird cocktail of genres has not disturbed me one bit!

Boxers & Saints

by Gene Luen Yang

This is my first experience of reading graphic novels and me likey! Boxers & Saints is an ambitious project: tell a story through simple drawings of two peasants caught up in a time of turmoil and sweeping change, all the while doing justice to the history. Author Gene Luen Yang succeeds, presenting a compassionate and often humorous version of China’s Boxer Rebellion from the perspectives of the warring factions. The Boxers were the commoners who trained in kung fu to fight off marauding bands of “foreign devils,” aka missionaries and soldiers. The Saints were locals who converted to Christianity, seeking safety and solace from the social breakdown of the time. Yang has both sides of his story drawing on mystical powers. The colourful Chinese gods aided and abetted the Boxers while the Christians sought divine intervention from glowing apparitions of martyred saints.

The Boxed Set

I was surprised at the medium’s versatility. Graphic novels use so few words to convey the story, and yet the effect is gut-wrenching and memorable. I never imagined a graphic novel would move me so. And the books, in their boxed set, are gorgeous. The smoothness of the matt finish of the covers and pages makes me purr. (Geeky and a little weird, I know. Sorry.)

**4 stars**

Etiquette & Espionage (Finishing School, Book #1)

by Gail Carriger

Okay, this one’s about as frothy as they come, but there’s nothing like steampunk to fire the imagination. A Victorian finishing school for young ladies of quality provides the setting, but it’s not your run-of-the-mill beauty school. These chicas are trained in poise, manners, and mortal combat (while avoiding mussing one’s doo and making sure one’s petticoat is not exposed.) The plucky, tomboyish protagonist, Sophronia Temminnick, quickly proves to be a major headache for her mentors, blundering along and embroiling herself into dangerous and highly unladylike situations. Carriger’s alternate Victorian world is a dark place where vampires and werewolves roam alongside mechanicals (steam-powered robots). I highly recommend the audio performance. Suitable for older MG/young YA readers.

**4 Stars**

The Thief (The Queen’s Thief, Book #1)

by Megan Whalen-Turner

As a writer of middle grade fiction, I search out and read high quality books in this category. The Thief, in addition to winning The Newbery Honor Award and some ALA awards, had umpteen rave recommendations online, with one literary agent claiming MWT (author) is “the goddess of POV.” Well, that did it for me. I ordered the first two books in the series.

The Thief is indeed a lesson in masterful POV (point of view) but also in skilful handling of the slow reveal. This is a treasure quest story, and it unfurls in such a delectable way. I’ve had writing mentors say that action is essential; readers will get bored if “nothing’s happening.” Well, you know what? Most of this book, the first 144 of 280 pages, covers not the exciting hunt for the treasure, but rather the laborious journey through the wilderness from the city to the site of the treasure. In that half, there’s not a lot of “action” or even excitement, but good stuff is going on. The dynamics between the members of the party play out. It all makes the twist at the end extra enjoyable. I think it’s fair to say that the author breaks a major writing rule with her fabulous finish (but I can’t say which rule it is without spoiling the ending). It just goes to show if you possess the skill and artistry to write a good story, you can break all the rules you want. The good folk at Newbery will even give you a silver badge for it!

**5 stars and looking forward to the Book #2***

The Wardrobe Girl

by Jennifer Smart

Reviewed here.

**4 Stars**

The Graveyard Book

by Neil Gaiman

It’s going to take every muscle in my body to resist the urge to gush. A book inspired by a childhood spent in libraries and written in homage to The Jungle Book? How’s that for a literary pedigree? Never mind the Hugo Award for Best Novel, the Locus Award, and the gold Newbery Medal on the cover. I only wish I had read it as a child, rather than as a semi-jaded adult, mainly because I’d like to know (by personal experience) how scary the villainous Jack is to kids. Does the thought of that glinting knife and its cold-blooded owner send shivers up the spine and kids scuttling under their blankets at night? The ghosts and ghouls and other creatures are lovable–no problems there (well, actually not the ghouls), but Jack…he’s another story…

The triple homicide of a family leaves its youngest member, a toddler, all alone in the world. In the aftermath of the grisly event, he wanders into a nearby graveyard, where he’s adopted by the resident ghosts–the friendly type–and dubbed Nobody Owens, “Bod” for short. There he stays all through his childhood, learning to read and write with headstones as books and old-fashioned personages directing his upbringing. He has (real) mythical mentors, a relentless enemy, and endless curiosity, all of which conspire to create fantastic adventures as he grows from toddlerhood into adolescence.

I’m trying to tempt you without revealing too much here. It’s so worth reading. I listened to the author’s performance of the book, yet another amazing talent to envy. (Here’s a sample of the good man’s narration with spooky visuals on YouTube.)

**5 swooning stars***

2014 Reading Challenge Status Update:

20% read, 2 books ahead of schedule. Go baby!

What Do You Think?

Have you read any of the books in my monthly reading round-up? I would love to know in the comments if you agree or disagree with my reviews.